Jul 11, 2022
Category: Roofing


Two of the most popular types of roofing materials are asphalt shingles and metal roofing. Many people want to know when it comes to a shingle roof vs metal roof, which one is better?


The durability of your roof is an essential factor to consider. Shingle roofing comes with warranties of 15-30 years. When installed properly, shingle roofing is plenty durable, but it does have its own set of weaknesses like moisture. If water penetrates the shingles, it can damage your roof and decrease its lifespan, especially if the water freezes and unfreezes. This, along with drastic changes in temperature, can affect the lifespan of a shingle roof.

Metal roofing often has warranties that span 30-50 years and can sometimes outlast its warranty. Metal roofing is also often considered Class A fire-rated and non-combustible, making it a great material for areas prone to wildfires. Since metal roofs don’t absorb water, you won’t have to worry about them breaking down due to moisture. They are also engineered in a way that allows them to move and flex with changes in temperature without being damaged.

Most Durable: Metal Roofing


A major factor to consider when choosing a roofing material is how much it will cost and whether or not it will fit into your budget. In general, an asphalt shingle roof is going to be less expensive than a metal roof. The materials for the roof are going to be cheaper to acquire. The installation process is also more straightforward, so the cost of hiring a professional roofer for the installation is very reasonable.

Metal roofing is going to come with a higher price tag than shingles. Installing a metal roof also requires a higher level of skill and expertise, so getting an experienced roofer on the job may cost you a little more. However, since metal roofing tends to have a longer lifespan, you won’t need to do repairs or a replacement as quickly or as often as you might with asphalt shingles.

Most Affordable: Asphalt Shingles

Energy Efficiency

Another important consideration is how energy efficient your roof will be. Asphalt shingles are great in the winter time since they absorb heat and can help keep your home warm. However, they still absorb heat in the summertime, so they don’t do a lot in helping keep your home cool.

Metal roofing offers more when it comes to energy efficiency. This material can be great at reducing energy consumption in the summer as long as it is installed correctly. In addition to being energy efficient for your home, metal roofing is also more environmentally friendly since it can be made from recycled materials and is continuously recyclable.

Most Energy Efficient: Metal Roofing

Curb Appeal

When it comes to the curb appeal of a shingle roof vs metal roof, it is often simply a matter of opinion. Shingle manufacturing has come a long way, and there are tons of different colors and styles available. Some shingles can be made to look like slate or tile, while others have varying textures to give your roof depth and visual appeal.

Metal roofing also has tons of options when it comes to how it looks. Metal roofing has come a long way since the days of rustic tin panels that were typically used for barns or sheds. The metal is often made to mimic other roofing materials like wood shakes or terra cotta. You can get metal roofing in just about any color as well, so you can match it with your home’s existing aesthetic.

Most Curb Appeal: Both

Invest in a Shingle or Metal Roof with Manor Roofing

Manor Roofing is well equipped to complete any shingle or metal roof. Our traditional shingle roofs are guaranteed to last. Long-lasting, beautiful, traditional roofs are a great investment for any mid-Missouri home or business. Our metal roofs are proudly made in the U.S. with Energy Star Approved pigments that help reflect more of the sun’s rays, keeping your home or business cooler in the summer months. Visit the website to schedule a free estimate for your next roofing project and to discuss whether a shingle roof vs metal roof is right for you!

Related Posts

When it comes to selecting the right roofing material for your property, understanding the options available is...

When considering roofing options for your home, durability and longevity are often top concerns. Metal roofing, known...

Your deck is more than just an outdoor extension of your home; it’s a place where memories are made, from sunny...